Belift Lab’s YouTube explanation video addressing plagiarism allegations has received mixed reactions, particularly criticism for using unreliable sources, manipulating idol photos, and escalating the conflict. Critics argue the video has damaged Belift Lab’s credibility and highlighted the challenges of managing two groups under the same label involved in a public dispute.
Introduction
In response to Belift Lab’s explanatory video uploaded on YouTube regarding the plagiarism allegations surrounding NewJeans and ILLIT, netizens have expressed mixed reactions. While some have shown support, others have criticized the video’s content and approach. This article delves into the key points of netizen reactions, particularly those from the online community “theqoo”.
YouTube Video Dislikes
The video has garnered over 50,000 dislikes, a significant number even if attributed primarily to NewJeans fans. This substantial negative response suggests that the video has failed to satisfy many viewers.
Usage of DCinside Material
Belift Lab’s video has been criticized for using material from DCinside, a popular Korean online community known for its informal and often unreliable nature. This choice of source has raised questions about the credibility of the video’s content.
Altering Idol Photos for Evidence
In an attempt to refute claims of plagiarism, Belift Lab compared NewJeans’ hanbok photos to those of other idols, implying that pastel-colored hanboks are commonly used among girl groups. However, allegations have surfaced that Belift Lab manipulated these photos to strengthen their argument, further fueling distrust.
Critics’ Views
Music critics have expressed concerns that Belift Lab’s video has exacerbated the situation rather than providing a genuine explanation. They argue that the video has intensified the conflict between NewJeans and ILLIT fans, particularly considering that both groups are under HYBE Labels.
Dragging Other Groups into the Conflict
Belift Lab’s use of images from other girl groups, such as GFRIEND and BLACKPINK, to emphasize NewJeans’ influences has drawn criticism from fans of those groups. This action has been perceived as insensitive and unnecessary, dragging unrelated parties into the conflict.
Conclusion
The consensus among netizens, particularly those on theqoo, is that Belift Lab’s manipulation of idol photos is an inexcusable error that undermines the credibility of the entire explanation video. This misstep has overshadowed any valid arguments presented, further complicating the issue. Moreover, the public conflict between NewJeans and ILLIT, both under HYBE Labels, raises concerns about the management company’s handling of the situation.
I appreciate you taking the time to read this post. Please share your thoughts in the comments!